Photoshop Object Removal: Remove Tool vs Contextual Remove Button Compared

Photoshop Object Removal: Remove Tool vs Contextual Remove Button Compared

Photoshop offers two main approaches for removing unwanted objects: the Remove Tool brush and the contextual Remove button that appears after making selections. Each method has distinct advantages depending on your image and workflow needs.

This comparison explores both techniques across multiple real-world examples to help you choose the most effective approach for different removal scenarios.

Watch the Tutorial

Video by Matt Kloskowski. Any links or downloads mentioned by the creator are available only on YouTube

Key Techniques for Object Removal

  • Use the Remove Tool for faster selections — The brush automatically closes loops around objects, eliminating manual selection work for most removal tasks.
  • Choose Gen AI On for better fills — While slightly lower in resolution, generative AI consistently produces more accurate removal results than traditional content-aware methods.
  • Try Select Subject for background replacement — When removing everything except the main subject, use Select Subject followed by the Remove button for quick results.
  • Switch methods when results disappoint — Different removal technologies work better on different image types, so experiment with both approaches if your first attempt fails.
  • Expect some cleanup work — Both methods may leave small artifacts that require additional touch-up with healing tools, especially on detailed textures like branches or grass.

Explore more techniques for removing unwanted elements from your photos.

How to Remove Unwanted Objects in Different Ways in Photoshop
Do you have photographs with distracting elements that need removing? In this insightful Photoshop tutorial from artist Zak Eazy, viewers will learn several effective techniques for eliminating unwanted objects from their images. Whether it's removing superfluous signs, wires or passersby, Zak walks through practical use cases that showcase the Patch and Clone Stamp tools as well as Content-Aware Fill. Through demonstration on real-world sample images, viewers will gain an understanding of when
The 3 Easiest Ways To Cut Out Images In Photoshop
In this informative tutorial, author Brendan Williams shares three of the most effective techniques for image cropping in Photoshop. The guide covers the infamous Quick Selection Tool, the Channels method, and the highly versatile Pen Tool. Whether you're a newcomer to the program or a seasoned professional, these methods are sure to elevate your workflow and take your work to new heights. The Quick Selection Tool, known for its intuitive and efficient selection capabilities, is explored in-dep
How to Remove People From Photos in Photoshop: Easy and Advanced Methods
Removing unwanted elements from photographs, especially people, is a common task in digital image editing. Whether you're a professional photographer or an enthusiast, the ability to clean up a scene can transform an ordinary shot into a compelling visual, allowing the true subject or landscape to shine without distractions. This video explores two distinct approaches to achieve this in Photoshop. Viewers will discover how to use the automated features for simpler scenarios involving crowds, an

Get tutorials & freebies delivered to you.

Subscribe to the Photoshop Roadmap newsletter, a weekly roundup of new tutorials, insights and quality downloads, trusted by 6500+ readers.

You might also like

How to Wrap Designs Around Complex Objects Using Displacement Maps in Photoshop

Professional mockups require more than simply placing a design onto an object. Complex surfaces like crushed aluminum cans demand advanced techniques to achieve realistic wrapping that follows every contour and deformation. This process combines displacement mapping, smart objects, and blending modes to create reusable templates that automatically conform any design...

How to Fix Three Confusing Default Settings in Photoshop

Sometimes Photoshop's default settings can make beginners think their software or hardware is broken. Images that fly around uncontrollably when panning, scroll bars appearing on full-size images, and zoom tools that seem to have a mind of their own are all caused by simple preference settings that can...

How to Create Better Shadows Than Drop Shadow in Photoshop

The basic drop shadow effect often looks flat and artificial compared to how shadows actually behave in real environments. Professional designers know that convincing shadows require understanding light direction, surface interaction, and atmospheric perspective. This technique demonstrates how to create custom shadows that respond naturally to your composition's...

How to Customize Your Photoshop Toolbar and Find Hidden Tools

A cluttered toolbar can slow down your workflow when you can't find the tools you need. Meanwhile, dozens of useful tools remain hidden in groups or completely out of sight. Learning to customize your toolbar lets you organize tools according to your actual workflow, remove tools you never...

How to Change Backgrounds and Match Lighting in Photoshop

Creating seamless background replacements requires more than just cutting out your subject. The real challenge lies in making the new composition look natural through proper lighting, color matching, and depth of field consistency. Modern Photoshop tools have simplified this process significantly, allowing you to achieve professional results with automated background...

How to Create a Colorful Aura Effect for Portraits in Photoshop

Portrait photography becomes truly captivating when enhanced with atmospheric effects that draw the viewer's eye. The colorful aura effect transforms ordinary portraits into striking visual statements by surrounding the subject with ethereal, glowing light that feels both magical and professional. This technique works best with portraits shot against...

You’ve successfully subscribed to Photoshop Roadmap
Welcome back! You’ve successfully signed in.
Great! You’ve successfully signed up.
Success! Your email is updated.
Your link has expired
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.